17 Best Restaurants in The Hamptons

The Hamptons, known for its picturesque landscapes and luxury real estate, is also home to an array of dining establishments that cater to every palate. From seaside bistros to fine dining, the restaurant scene in The Hamptons offers something for everyone. Below, we explore seventeen of the best restaurants in The Hamptons, each bringing its own unique flavor to this iconic region.

Le Bilboquet is a chic French bistro in Sag Harbor. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and celebrity clientele, it serves classic French cuisine with a modern twist. Signature dishes like the Cajun chicken and tuna tartare have made it a must-visit for both locals and visitors.

Il Buco Al Mare in Amagansett brings the flavors of the Mediterranean to The Hamptons. With its emphasis on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, this restaurant offers a menu that changes with the seasons. The rustic yet elegant setting perfectly complements the coastal-inspired dishes, making it a favorite among seafood lovers.

Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton is a long-standing favorite, celebrated for its Italian-inspired menu and warm, inviting ambiance. The restaurant is renowned for its wood-fired pizzas and farm-to-table dishes. With a reputation for excellent service and a cozy environment, Nick & Toni’s remains a top choice for fine dining in The Hamptons.

Perched on the water’s edge in Montauk, Duryea’s offers stunning views alongside its seafood-centric menu. This casual yet sophisticated spot is famous for its lobster rolls, oysters, and other fresh seafood delights. The relaxed atmosphere and beautiful scenery make it a perfect place for a leisurely meal.

Talya Montauk offers a contemporary dining experience with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. This restaurant is located in Montauk and combines a modern menu with a laid-back, beachy vibe. Diners can enjoy creative dishes inspired by Mediterranean and Middle Eastern flavors while enjoying breathtaking ocean views.

Sí Sí, located in East Hampton, is a Mediterranean-inspired restaurant known for its vibrant flavors and stylish setting. The menu features a mix of traditional and innovative dishes, emphasizing fresh seafood and locally sourced produce. Sí Sí’s chic ambiance makes it a popular destination for casual and special occasions.

O by Kissaki in Water Mill offers an elevated sushi dining experience emphasizing the art of omakase. This modern Japanese restaurant is celebrated for its meticulously prepared sushi and sashimi and thoughtful selection of sake. Its intimate setting and expert craftsmanship make it a standout in the Hamptons dining scene.

SALT, located on Shelter Island, is a waterfront restaurant that offers a laid-back dining experience focusing on fresh, local seafood. The menu is simple yet flavorful, featuring dishes like fish tacos and clam chowder. With its relaxed atmosphere and scenic views, SALT is perfect for a casual meal by the water.

Carissa’s Bakery in East Hampton is a must-visit for those with a sweet tooth. Known for its artisanal breads and pastries, this bakery offers a delightful selection of baked goods made with locally sourced ingredients. Carissa’s Bakery is a beloved spot for breakfast or a midday treat, from fresh croissants to seasonal pies.

Beacon in Sag Harbor is a waterfront restaurant with stunning sunset views and a menu inspired by coastal cuisine. The dishes at Beacon are crafted with fresh, seasonal ingredients, and the menu features a variety of seafood options. The restaurant’s scenic location and relaxed atmosphere make it a popular choice for dinner and drinks.

Alimentari Beach in Amagansett offers a casual dining experience focusing on Italian-inspired dishes. The menu features a variety of pizzas, pasta, and salads, all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The relaxed, beachy vibe and delicious food make Alimentari Beach an excellent spot for a laid-back meal with friends or family.

Crow’s Nest in Montauk is known for its bohemian vibe and beautiful lakeside setting. The restaurant offers a menu highlighting seasonal, locally sourced ingredients focusing on fresh seafood and produce. Crow’s Nest’s relaxed atmosphere and stunning views make it a favorite among locals and visitors.

Coche Comedor in Amagansett offers a taste of Mexico in The Hamptons. The restaurant’s menu features traditional Mexican dishes made with fresh, local ingredients, including tacos, ceviche, and churros. With its lively atmosphere and flavorful dishes, Coche Comedor is a popular spot for lunch and dinner.

Sunset Beach is located on Shelter Island and offers a dining experience with a French Riviera flair. The restaurant’s menu is inspired by Mediterranean cuisine, featuring dishes like grilled fish and bouillabaisse. The beachfront location and relaxed ambiance make it an ideal spot for a leisurely meal or a sunset cocktail.

Mostrador Marram in Montauk is a casual beachfront eatery that offers a selection of fresh, seasonal dishes. The menu is inspired by the coastal environment and features a variety of small plates, salads, and sandwiches. With its laid-back vibe and focus on local ingredients, Mostrador Marram is a great place to enjoy a light, flavorful meal by the sea.

Pierre’s in Bridgehampton is a French bistro that offers a taste of Provence in the heart of The Hamptons. Known for its elegant, yet relaxed atmosphere, Pierre’s features a menu filled with French classics like coq au vin, escargots, and crème brûlée. The restaurant’s sophisticated ambiance and attentive service make it a popular choice for a refined dining experience.

East Hampton Grill offers classic American cuisine in a refined setting. Known for its steaks, seafood, and signature biscuits, the restaurant provides a sophisticated dining experience focusing on high-quality ingredients. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make East Hampton Grill a favorite for locals and visitors.

With over two decades of experience, Katie Haggerty has built lasting relationships with clients across The Hamptons, NYC, and beyond. Her journey brought her to The Agency in the Hamptons, where she represents industry leaders such as Mauricio Umansky, Dana Trotter, and Tyler Whitman from Bravo’s Million Dollar Listing. Katie joined The Agency’s Bridgehampton office in the summer of 2023, contributing to one of the fastest-growing boutique brokerage brands, known as the Top Luxury Brokerage by Inman. Her extensive portfolio includes high-end residential sales, rentals, investments, and land opportunities. Katie is highly skilled in negotiating property contracts and tirelessly advocating for her clients.

If you're looking to buy or sell a home or have any questions about the real estate market in The Hamptons, contact Katie Haggerty today.